How Can a Foreign Company Defend Itself Against a Fine Imposed by a Czech Authority?

Receiving a fine from a Czech authority can be a disorienting experience for any foreign company. This article provides a clear, step-by-step guide to help you understand your rights and build a strong defense. As a leading Czech law firm with extensive experience representing international clients, ARROWS offers the expertise you need. If you are looking for an English-speaking lawyer to defend against a fine, our team, based in Prague, European Union, is ready to assist you.

Need advice on this topic? Contact ARROWS Law Firm at office@arws.cz or +420 245 007 740. Your question will be answered by "JUDr. Jakub Dohnal, Ph.D., LL.M.", an expert on the topic.

First Steps After Receiving a Fine from a Czech Authority

The initial moments after receiving an official notice of a penalty are critical. Understanding the document and acting decisively can significantly alter the outcome. The most common and costly mistake is inaction, which allows the fine to become legally final and opens your company to severe enforcement measures.

Understanding the Notice: Who Fined You and Why?

The Czech Republic has a robust regulatory framework enforced by numerous specialized administrative bodies. A fine is not just from "the government"; it comes from a specific authority with jurisdiction over a particular area of law. Recognizing the issuing body is the first step in formulating a defense strategy, as each has its own procedural nuances.

Foreign companies commonly face penalties from authorities such as:

• The Financial Administration (Finanční správa): This is the Czech tax authority. Fines often relate to late tax filings, incorrect VAT calculations, or breaches of tax confidentiality. Penalties can include a surcharge of 20% of any additionally assessed tax, plus late payment interest, which is calculated at the Czech National Bank's repo rate plus eight percentage points.
• The State Labour Inspectorate (Státní úřad inspekce práce): This body enforces employment law. A major focus is on "illegal employment," which includes hiring foreign workers before all documentation is registered with the Labour Office. Fines for allowing illegal work can reach up to CZK 10,000,000 (approximately EUR 400,000), and companies may also be banned from hiring foreign nationals.
• The Czech Trade Inspection Authority (Česká obchodní inspekce): This authority oversees consumer protection, a critical area for e-commerce businesses and retailers. Fines can be imposed for misleading advertising, unfair commercial terms, or improper handling of customer complaints, with penalties for aggressive practices reaching up to CZK 5,000,000.
• The Office for Personal Data Protection (Úřad pro ochranu osobních údajů): Responsible for enforcing the GDPR, this office has demonstrated its willingness to impose substantial fines. In a recent high-profile case, it fined Avast Software CZK 351 million (approximately EUR 13.9 million) for unlawful processing of user data, signaling a strict enforcement environment for all companies handling personal data.

The diversity and severity of these penalties show that compliance is not a passive requirement but an active, ongoing necessity for any business operating in the Czech Republic. 

A violation in one area can easily trigger scrutiny in another, making a comprehensive legal strategy essential not only for resolving current issues but also for preventing future ones. This is why ARROWS provides services that extend beyond litigation, including the preparation of internal company policies and professional training for employees.

The Most Common Mistake: Ignoring the Decision

Upon receiving a penalty notice, some foreign managers may be tempted to delay or ignore it, especially if the legal basis seems unclear or unfair. This is a critical error. Under Czech law, an administrative decision that is not challenged within the prescribed time limit becomes final and legally enforceable.

This means the state gains the right to compel payment through a powerful enforcement process known as exekuce. This process can lead to the freezing of company bank accounts, seizure of property, and significant disruption to your business operations. Acting promptly is not just advisable; it is the only way to protect your company's assets and preserve your right to a defense.

Risks and penalties	How ARROWS helps
"Illegal Employment" of Foreign Workers: Fine up to CZK 10,000,000 and a potential ban on hiring foreigners for allowing work to begin before official registration is complete.	Drafting compliant documentation: We prepare employment contracts and internal hiring policies to prevent violations. Need to review your procedures? Contact us at office@arws.cz.
GDPR Violations: The Office for Personal Data Protection has issued fines as high as CZK 351 million (€13.9M) for unlawful data processing.	Legal analysis and representation: We analyze the alleged breach and represent you before the authority. Want to understand your legal options? Email us at office@arws.cz.
Tax Non-Compliance: Penalties include a 20% surcharge on additionally assessed tax, plus significant late payment interest (currently over 10% p.a.).	Consultations to prevent penalties: Our tax experts help you navigate complex Czech tax laws to ensure compliance. For immediate assistance, write to us at office@arws.cz.
E-commerce Consumer Protection Breach: Fines of up to CZK 5,000,000 can be levied for using aggressive or misleading commercial practices, such as unfair terms for contract withdrawal.	Contract review and drafting: We ensure your terms and conditions are fully compliant with Czech and EU consumer law. Do you need a contract prepared? Contact us at office@arws.cz.

 

The Administrative Appeal: Your Immediate Defense

The Czech legal system provides a clear, structured path for challenging an administrative fine. The first and most important step is the administrative appeal. This is not merely a procedural formality; it is a powerful strategic tool that, when used correctly, can immediately shield your company from financial harm.

The Critical 15-Day Deadline

The foundational law governing administrative procedures is the Administrative Code (správní řád, Act No. 500/2004 Coll.). This law establishes a strict deadline for filing an appeal (odvolání). You must submit your appeal to the authority that issued the fine within 15 days of the official delivery of the decision.

This 15-day window is absolute. Missing it means you forfeit your right to an administrative appeal, and the decision becomes final. It is therefore essential to contact legal counsel the moment you receive a notice to ensure this critical deadline is met.

The Power of "Suspensive Effect" (Odkladný účinek)

The most compelling reason to act immediately is the "suspensive effect" (odkladný účinek) of a timely appeal. Filing an appeal within the 15-day deadline automatically pauses the legal effect of the decision. This means the decision is not yet final, the fine is not yet due, and the authorities cannot initiate enforcement actions against you.

This legal shield is an invaluable, yet perishable, asset. It transforms the appeal from a simple legal filing into an urgent business maneuver that preserves your cash flow, protects your assets, and gives your legal team the time needed to build a robust defense on the merits of the case. Failing to act within 15 days is not just a missed legal deadline; it is the forfeiture of your company's primary defensive shield.

The Special Case: Appealing a Central Authority Decision (Rozklad)

To showcase a deeper level of expertise, it is important to understand a specific type of appeal known as a rozklad. While an odvolání is the standard appeal against a decision from a regional or local authority, a rozklad is the proper remedy for decisions issued by a central government body, such as a ministry or the Czech National Bank (ČNB).

The procedure is similar, including the 15-day deadline, but the decision on the rozklad is made by the head of that central authority (e.g., the Minister or the Bank Board). This decision is based on a recommendation from a special advisory body, the appeal committee (rozkladová komise), which is composed of legal and financial experts. Understanding this distinction is crucial when dealing with high-stakes financial or regulatory penalties.

What Must Your Appeal Contain?

A simple letter of disagreement is insufficient. To be valid, your appeal must meet specific formal requirements. It must clearly state:

• Which decision it is directed against.
• The extent to which you are contesting it (e.g., the entire decision or only the amount of the fine).
• The specific legal and factual arguments explaining why the decision or the preceding procedure was incorrect or in conflict with the law.

It is vital to support your arguments with all relevant evidence from the outset, such as contracts, internal policies, financial statements, or correspondence. The strength of your initial appeal can determine whether the matter is resolved quickly or proceeds to a more lengthy and costly court battle.

FAQ – Legal tips on starting your appeal

• How is the 15-day deadline calculated?
  The clock starts the day after you officially receive the decision. The appeal is considered timely if it is handed to a postal service on the 15th day. For immediate assistance calculating your deadline, write to us at office@arws.cz.
• Do I have to pay the fine before I can appeal?
  No. The suspensive effect of a timely appeal means the obligation to pay is paused until the appeal is decided. Need legal help? Contact us at office@arws.cz.
• Can I just send an email saying I disagree?
  No, the appeal has formal requirements. It must clearly state the legal and factual reasons for your challenge. Our lawyers are ready to draft a compelling appeal for you – email us at office@arws.cz.

Beyond the Appeal: Taking Your Case to Court

If the administrative appeal is unsuccessful and the authority upholds its original decision, the fight is not over. The Czech legal system guarantees the right to judicial review, allowing you to take your case out of the hands of the administrative body and before an independent court.

When the Administrative Appeal Fails: Judicial Review

Once you receive a final decision on your appeal, you can challenge its legality in court. This is done by filing an "action against a decision of an administrative authority" (správní žaloba). This legal action asks the court to review the administrative authority's decision for legal and procedural errors. The court has the power to annul the decision, send it back to the authority for reassessment, or, in cases involving penalties, even reduce or waive the fine entirely.

The 2-Month Deadline and Where to File

Just as with the administrative appeal, there is a strict deadline for initiating judicial review. You must file your správní žaloba within two months of being served the final decision from the appeal body.

The action is filed with the competent Regional Court (krajský soud). Crucially, the correct court is determined by the location of the administrative authority that issued the first-instance decision, not the appeal body. Filing in the wrong venue can cause delays that jeopardize your case, making local legal expertise indispensable.

The Role of the Supreme Administrative Court

If you are unsuccessful at the Regional Court, a final avenue of appeal exists. You can file a "cassation complaint" (kasační stížnost) with the Supreme Administrative Court (Nejvyšší správní soud), located in Brno.

This is not a full re-hearing of the case. The Supreme Administrative Court's review is limited to specific grounds, such as a significant violation of procedural rules or an incorrect interpretation of the law by the lower court. Importantly, representation by a licensed lawyer is mandatory for cassation complaints. This underscores the increasing legal complexity as a case moves up the judicial ladder.

The existence of this multi-layered review process—from the initial authority to an internal appeal body, then to a Regional Court, and finally to the Supreme Administrative Court—provides multiple, distinct opportunities to challenge a flawed decision. It transforms the process from a single, high-stakes event into a strategic campaign. 

A legal argument may be more persuasive to an independent judge than to the administrative body that issued the fine. Success requires a legal partner who can develop a sophisticated, multi-stage litigation strategy tailored to each phase of the process. The entire judicial review process is governed by the Code of Administrative Justice (soudní řád správní, Act No. 150/2002 Coll.).

Risks and penalties	How ARROWS helps
Missing the 2-month deadline to file a court action: This results in the permanent loss of the right to judicial review. The fine becomes final and fully enforceable.	Meticulous deadline tracking: We ensure all court actions are prepared and filed on time. We provide representation in court proceedings. Need legal representation? Write to office@arws.cz.
Filing with the wrong court: This procedural error can lead to the dismissal of your case, potentially causing you to miss the filing deadline altogether.	Expert procedural navigation: We identify the correct competent court based on the specific details of your case, ensuring a smooth and valid filing. Get tailored legal solutions by writing to office@arws.cz.
Failure to secure mandatory legal representation: A cassation complaint filed with the Supreme Administrative Court without a lawyer is automatically rejected.	Authorized representation at all levels: Our experienced litigators are authorized to represent clients before all Czech courts, including the Supreme Administrative Court. For expert representation, email us at office@arws.cz.

 

Understanding the Czech Legal Landscape: Key Differences for Foreign Clients

For businesses headquartered in common law jurisdictions like the United States, the United Kingdom, or Australia, navigating the Czech legal system can present unexpected challenges. The Czech Republic is part of the continental (Germanic) civil law tradition, which operates on different principles. Understanding these differences is key to building a successful defense.

A common pitfall for foreign clients arises from a misunderstanding of procedural norms. For instance, a client accustomed to the adversarial system might be inclined to hold back key evidence during the initial administrative appeal, expecting a later "discovery" phase where they can build their case. 

This would be a strategic disaster in the Czech system. The administrative process has inquisitorial features, meaning the authority actively investigates and expects all arguments and evidence to be presented upfront. Failing to do so can fatally weaken your case from the very beginning.

Two key conceptual differences are:

1. Inquisitorial vs. Adversarial System: In a classic adversarial system, two opposing parties present their cases to a neutral judge. In Czech administrative proceedings, the authority itself plays a more active, inquisitorial role in establishing the facts. This means your initial appeal must be comprehensive and well-supported, as it is your primary opportunity to shape the factual record.

2. The Role of Precedent: In common law, the doctrine of stare decisis means that decisions from higher courts are strictly binding precedent. In the Czech system, while previous decisions of higher courts (judikatura) are highly persuasive and create "settled case-law" that lower courts and authorities follow, they are not formally binding in the same way. Legal arguments must be based primarily on the text of the relevant statutes, supported by case law.

As an international law firm operating from Prague, European Union, ARROWS excels at bridging these legal and cultural gaps. Our lawyers have a deep understanding of both local and foreign legal frameworks. Through our ARROWS International network, built over 10 years, we provide our clients with seamless cross-border legal support, translating not just the language but the entire legal mindset to prevent costly strategic errors.

The High Cost of Inaction: The Enforcement (Exekuce) Process

Failing to challenge a fine, or losing all appeals, has severe and immediate consequences. Once all deadlines have passed, the administrative decision achieves právní moc (legal finality) and vykonatelnost (enforceability). At this point, the state is no longer asking for payment; it is empowered to take it by force.

When a Fine Becomes Final and Enforceable

An enforceable decision is an "enforcement title," a legal document that authorizes the state to initiate collection proceedings, known as správní exekuce. The administrative authority that issued the fine can either conduct the enforcement itself (for non-monetary obligations) or, more commonly for financial penalties, hand the case over to a court-appointed private bailiff, the soudní exekutor.

The Powers of the Enforcement Authority

The powers of a Czech exekutor are extensive and designed for swift, effective collection. Once authorized by a court, a bailiff can take immediate action that can paralyze a company's operations. The threat is not a distant, bureaucratic process; it is an acute operational risk that can materialize with little warning.

An exekutor has the legal authority to seize a wide range of company assets, including:

• Freezing and seizing funds from all Czech bank accounts.
• Placing liens on and forcing the sale of real estate.
• Seizing movable property, such as company vehicles, equipment, and inventory.
• Seizing company shares or ownership interests.
• Garnishing receivables from your business partners.

The goal of fighting an administrative fine is therefore not just about mitigating a financial liability on your balance sheet. It is about preventing a sudden and potentially catastrophic disruption to your business.

FAQ – Legal tips on enforcement risks

• Can a Czech authority seize assets my company holds outside the Czech Republic?
  While direct seizure is complex, a final Czech judgment is enforceable across the EU under regulations like the Recast Brussels Regulation. Our lawyers are ready to assist you with cross-border enforcement issues – email us at office@arws.cz.
• Will we receive a warning before our bank account is frozen?
  You will be notified that enforcement proceedings have begun, but the actual freezing of an account by a bailiff can happen very quickly to prevent the debtor from moving funds. For immediate assistance, write to us at office@arws.cz.
• What if our company has no assets in the Czech Republic?
  The unpaid fine remains a legal liability. It can hinder future business, affect your company's reputation, and may be enforced later if the company acquires assets or if it can be enforced in your home jurisdiction within the EU. Get tailored legal solutions by writing to office@arws.cz.

Your Strategic Partner in Prague: How ARROWS Defends Your Interests

Successfully challenging an administrative fine in the Czech Republic requires more than just knowledge of the law. It demands strategic foresight, procedural precision, and an intimate understanding of how local authorities and courts operate. As a leading Czech law firm in Prague, EU, ARROWS provides the comprehensive support your business needs to navigate this complex process.

Our firm is built on a reputation for speed and high quality, supporting over 150 joint-stock companies and 250 limited liability companies. With a presence in 90 countries through our international network, we are uniquely positioned to understand the needs of foreign clients. We not only defend your interests but can also connect you with other clients for mutual business or investment opportunities.

ARROWS offers a full suite of services to manage your case from start to finish:

• Legal analysis of the initial decision to identify weaknesses and grounds for appeal.
• Drafting and filing of timely and persuasive administrative appeals (odvolání and rozklad).
• Representation in court before the Regional Courts and the Supreme Administrative Court.
• Negotiation with administrative authorities to seek favorable settlements where appropriate.
• Preparation of preventative internal policies to minimize the risk of future fines.
• Professional training for your management and employees on Czech compliance requirements.

Do not let an administrative fine disrupt your business. Let our experience be your advantage.

FAQ – Most common legal questions about challenging Czech administrative fines

 

• How much does it cost to appeal a fine?
  The costs involve administrative fees and legal fees. The total cost depends on the complexity of the case and the stages required (administrative appeal vs. full court proceedings). We provide transparent fee structures. To discuss your case, please contact us at office@arws.cz.

 

• Can the fine be increased if I lose the appeal?
  It is highly unlikely for the fine to be increased during the appeal process. The goal of the appeal is to have the fine cancelled or reduced. The primary risk of an unsuccessful appeal is incurring legal costs. Want to understand your legal options? Email us at office@arws.cz.

• How long does the entire appeal process take?
  The administrative appeal stage can take several months. If the case proceeds to court, it can take a year or more to get a first-instance decision, with a potential further year for a Supreme Administrative Court ruling. For a specific timeline estimate, get in touch with our team at office@arws.cz.

• My company is based in the US/UK. Why can't my home lawyer handle this?
  Czech administrative law is a highly specialized field governed by specific local codes (správní řád, soudní řád správní) and procedures. Effective representation requires deep knowledge of Czech law, language, and court practices. Do not hesitate to contact our firm – office@arws.cz.

• What are our chances of success?
  Success depends entirely on the specific facts of your case, the evidence available, and the legal arguments that can be made. We can provide a preliminary assessment of your case's strengths and weaknesses after reviewing the authority's decision. For an initial consultation, write to us at office@arws.cz.

• We think the fine is unfair, but is it worth fighting over a small amount?
  Even a small fine can be a red flag for authorities, potentially leading to future audits and scrutiny. Challenging an incorrect decision can be a strategic investment in your company's long-term compliance reputation in the Czech Republic. Need strategic legal advice? Contact us at office@arws.cz.

Don't want to deal with this problem yourself? More than 2,000 clients trust ARROWS Law Firm, and we have been named Law Firm of the Year 2024. Take a look HERE at our references, and we will be honored to help you solve your problem. The inquiry is free of charge.